Unsolved Murders in Great Falls, Montana: A True Crime Deep Dive

The Bogle and Kitzky Murders (1956)

• 💔 18-year-old Lloyd Bogle and 16-year-old Patricia Kitzky were found murdered after a date at a drive-in restaurant.
• 🔫 Both were shot in the back of the head, and their bodies were discovered in different locations, with Patricia found seven miles from Lloyd.
• 🕵️‍♂️ Initial theories of robbery were dismissed due to money and a camera being left at the scene.
• 🌲 In an unusual investigative step, a 150-year-old cottonwood tree was cut down in 1989 in hopes of finding the bullet that killed Lloyd, yielding eight bullets of various calibers, but no definitive leads.
• 🚫 The case remains unsolved, with serial killer Edward Wayne Edwards having a tenuous connection due to his presence in Great Falls at the time.

The Arata Double Murder (1964)

• 🛒 James and Lois Arata were found brutally murdered in their grocery store, both beaten with glass Pepsi bottles and stabbed multiple times with a produce knife.
• 💰 The motive appeared to be robbery, but the killer only made off with $37, as a time-delay safe could not be opened.
• 🚗 Investigators believe the killer abducted the couple from their home, forced them to the store, and then returned to their home to steal a coin collection.
• 🔍 Despite extensive investigation, including fingerprint analysis, no match was found, and the case went cold.
• ⚖️ In 2002, Allan Revly was charged 37 years later but was found not guilty in 2004 due to a lack of physical evidence.

The Dudas Murder (1974)

• 🏠 75-year-old Michael Dudas was shot three times in his apartment after an intruder entered while he was preparing for bed.
• 🔫 The murder weapon was believed to be a small caliber handgun, possibly a .22.
• 🚪 The killer left the apartment door wide open, and no evidence of theft was found, leading to theories of a hit or random murder.
• 🔗 A bizarre connection exists as serial killer Edward Wayne Edwards had previously lived in the same apartment 18 years prior, though no proof links him to this murder.
• ❓ The case generated 50 leads but remains unsolved.

The Davis and Pritchard Murders (1985-1986)

• 🍕 23-year-old Morris Davis Jr. was shot and killed while delivering pizzas, with the motive appearing to be robbery of his money pouch.
• 🔪 Just over a year later, 18-year-old convenience store clerk Susette Pritchard was stabbed 24 times and robbed of $300.
• 🔫 In 1988, Donald Dubre was investigated due to ballistics matching a stolen handgun to the Morris Davis murder, but the testing was deemed inaccurate.
• 💡 A 1997 informant tip suggested Dubre confessed to killing both Morris and Susette.
• ✅ Dubre was convicted of Susette Pritchard's murder in 1998 and sentenced to life, but never admitted to Morris Davis's murder, which remains unsolved.

Impact on Great Falls

• 🔒 These unsolved murders, spanning decades, significantly impacted the sense of security in Great Falls, Montana.
• 😨 Residents became more cautious, leading to changes in daily life, such as locking doors and altering business operations.
• ❓ The bizarre circumstances and lack of resolution in these cases have left a lasting mark on the community.