Retired Four-Star General Philip Breedlove on Refusing an Order to Invade Greenland
The Trump ReportJanuary 8, 202613 min51,011 views
3 connectionsΒ·5 entities in this videoβRefusal of an Invasion Order
- π‘ General Philip Breedlove, former Supreme Allied Commander of NATO, stated he would refuse an order to invade Greenland.
- π He clarified that military personnel are not obligated to follow orders that are illegal or immoral.
- β οΈ While not making a judgment on the legality of invading Greenland, he affirmed his personal stance: "Had I been given an order to invade Greenland, I would have said no."
Military Role in Domestic Policing
- π§ Breedlove expressed concern about the erosion of public trust in the military if it is used for domestic policing.
- πΊπΈ He cited historical events like Kent State as reasons to avoid deploying the military in such situations.
- π‘οΈ The general emphasized that the National Guard is a professional military force with significant combat experience.
Political Division and Leadership
- π£οΈ Breedlove believes that fringe political operators on both the left and right are driving the country further apart.
- π― He suggested that citizen politicians in the middle need to be empowered to govern effectively.
- βοΈ The current political climate is seen as a fight to divide Americans for political gain, which needs to change.
Congressional Oversight and War Powers
- ποΈ Breedlove noted that Congress is beginning to wake up to its responsibilities in national governance, referencing the War Powers Resolution concerning Venezuela.
- π He highlighted that Congress is also starting to build coalitions regarding the conversation about Greenland, indicating a growing awareness of its role.
- π€ The legislative branch is showing a willingness to be a part of how the nation runs, working across party lines.
Civil Control of the Military
- π Breedlove corrected the term 'political leaders' to 'civil leadership,' emphasizing that the military is beholden to civil authority, not political parties.
- βοΈ He referenced historical instances where soldiers used the defense of "we were ordered to do it" for illegal or immoral actions, which was deemed not a valid defense.
- π Refusing an illegal or immoral order, even with potential personal peril, is a recourse available through the courts and determination of right and wrong.
Knowledge graph5 entities Β· 3 connections
How they connect
An interactive map of every person, idea, and reference from this conversation. Hover to trace connections, click to explore.
Hover Β· drag to explore
5 entities
Chapters1 moments
Key Moments
Transcript49 segments
Full Transcript
Topics13 themes
Whatβs Discussed
Greenland InvasionPhilip BreedloveNATOIllegal OrdersImmoral OrdersMilitary EthicsDomestic PolicingNational GuardPolitical DivisionCivil Control of MilitaryWar Powers ResolutionCongressional OversightUS Military
Smart Objects5 Β· 3 links
PersonΒ· 1
EventΒ· 1
CompaniesΒ· 2
ConceptΒ· 1