Skip to main content

Reddit User Uncovers Eerie Mystery of Identical Stores in Their Town

Red WebJuly 18, 202247 min10,953 views
28 connections·40 entities in this video

The Strange Reddit Post

  • 💡 In July 2019, Reddit user u/icemanthrowaway123 (referred to as Iceman) posted about a confusing and strange experience in their town on the "Too Afraid To Ask" subreddit.
  • 📌 Iceman described living in a suburb where, after many businesses closed, 12 identical stores suddenly opened on the main street.
  • 🔑 These stores had similar names (e.g., "Town Market"), shared a consistent sign style, and sold a limited selection of grocery items.

Unsettling Store Observations

  • 🛒 The stores primarily stocked store-brand items from larger retailers, but sold them at significantly higher prices, suggesting an inefficient sourcing method.
  • 👁️ Despite having very few customers, the stores were heavily staffed with employees who would stare at and follow shoppers, creating an eerie atmosphere.
  • ⚠️ A strict policy required a minimum $50 purchase for credit card use, otherwise only cash was accepted, raising suspicions about financial transparency.
  • 🍎 Iceman discovered that nearly all products were expired, including bread that was two months past its date and had turned a "nasty shade of green."

Lack of Evidence and Disappearance

  • 📸 Despite requests from other Reddit users, no photos or verifiable proof of these stores or the expired goods were ever provided by Iceman.
  • ⏳ Iceman's last confirmed activity on the throwaway account was on the same day as the original post, July 29, 2019, leading to speculation about their sudden disappearance.
  • 💬 Excuses for the lack of photos included working late and friends being drunk when they supposedly saw the stores, which many found conveniently evasive.

Theories and Speculation

  • 🕵️ Many Reddit users, and the hosts, considered the possibility that the story was a hoax, citing the lack of evidence and the implausibility of such a public phenomenon going unnoticed.
  • 💰 A prominent theory suggests the stores were a front for organized crime, such as money laundering or food stamp fraud, drawing parallels to the "Mattress Firm conspiracy."
  • 🧠 Another theory, treated with caution, posited that Iceman might have been experiencing mental illness, leading to misinterpretations of their environment.
  • 🌌 A more fantastical theory proposed a "glitch in the matrix," where Iceman might have stumbled into an alternate, dystopian reality of their town.
Knowledge graph40 entities · 28 connections

How they connect

An interactive map of every person, idea, and reference from this conversation. Hover to trace connections, click to explore.

Hover · drag to explore
40 entities
Chapters20 moments

Key Moments

Transcript178 segments

Full Transcript

Topics12 themes

What’s Discussed

Reddit MysteryOnline IdentitiesStrange Retail StoresExpired FoodMoney LaunderingFood Stamp FraudConspiracy TheoriesThrowaway AccountsMattress Firm ConspiracyUnresolved MysteriesGlitch in the MatrixSuburb Mystery
Smart Objects40 · 28 links
People· 8
Medias· 3
Companies· 11
Locations· 5
Products· 5
Events· 2
Concepts· 6