Mazda MX-5 Miata (ND3) vs. Honda S2000 (AP1): POV Ownership Comparison

Miata ND3 vs. S2000 AP1: A Driving Comparison

• 🚗 The video compares a modified Mazda MX-5 Miata ND3 with an AP1 Honda S2000, highlighting their driving dynamics, ownership experiences, and overall appeal.
• 💡 Both cars are praised for their pure driving experience, with the Miata offering modern refinement and the S2000 providing raw thrills and an exciting engine.

Performance and Handling

• ⚡ The S2000 boasts a higher horsepower advantage (240 hp) with its legendary VTEC engine and 9,000 RPM redline, while the Miata has 181 hp from its Skyactiv 2.0L engine.
• ⚖️ The Miata has a significant weight advantage (around 2,300 lbs vs. 2,800 lbs for the S2000), contributing to its nimble feel.
• 🔧 Modifications on the Miata include sway bars and an exhaust, which significantly reduce body roll and enhance its sound, while the S2000 features Fortune Auto coilovers and exhaust work.
• 🏁 Both cars offer excellent handling, with the Miata feeling lighter and more approachable, and the S2000 providing a more raw and communicative chassis, especially with upgraded suspension.

Ownership and Practicality

• 🔑 The Miata is presented as a more practical and reliable long-term ownership proposition, with modern safety features, technology, and less maintenance required.
• 🛠️ The S2000, while a fantastic driver's car, requires more involved ownership due to its age, potential maintenance needs, and higher mileage.
• 💰 Both cars can be found for similar price points, with early ND Miatas and clean S2000s often trading in the $12,000-$20,000 range, while a new ND3 is in the mid to low $30,000s.

Interior and Comfort

• 🛋️ The Miata offers a more modern interior with better NVH (Noise, Vibration, Harshness) control and amenities like available CarPlay.
• 🤏 The S2000's cockpit can feel a bit tighter, with a higher driving position, though its stock seats are still highly regarded.
• 💨 Both convertibles provide a pleasant top-down driving experience with minimal wind buffeting at highway speeds.

Final Verdict

• ✨ For sheer driving thrills, the S2000, particularly the AP1 with its high-revving engine, edges out the Miata, offering a more raw and exciting experience.
• ✅ However, for overall ownership, daily drivability, and modern refinement, the ND Miata is the preferred choice, offering a fantastic balance of fun and practicality.
• 🏆 Ultimately, both cars are considered winners, providing exceptional driving enjoyment for their respective price points and target audiences.