Kristi Noem's LA Claims Debunked: Trump's Troop Deployment Deemed Illegal

Noem's Claim About Los Angeles

• 📌 Kristi Noem claimed that Los Angeles "wouldn't be standing today" and "would have burned down" if President Trump had not deployed the National Guard.
• 💡 She stated that federal law enforcement officers were crucial in bringing peace to downtown LA during riots and violence.

Legal Ruling on Troop Deployment

• ⚖️ A federal judge ruled that Trump illegally deployed the National Guard to Los Angeles.
• 🚫 The deployment violated a 19th-century law (Posse Comitatus Act) prohibiting the use of soldiers for civilian law enforcement without congressional approval.
• 🏛️ The judge found that the Trump administration exceeded its authority by using troops for policing activities, calling it a "military occupation."

Legal and Constitutional Arguments

• 📜 The transcript highlights that the National Guard is under a separate authoritative agency and that using military for policing is generally deemed unconstitutional.
• ⚠️ It is argued that presidents cannot act as the "commander in chief of police" in the US.
• 📜 The discussion also touches upon the US Constitution's Articles of War, which require congressional approval for creating such articles.

Political Implications and Concerns

• 🗣️ The actions are seen by some as an attempt by the president to establish a "national police force."
• 🚩 There is a concern that this trend could lead to a dictatorship or police state, with potential control over citizens' rights to gather, speak, and vote.
• 📢 Some individuals who previously voted for Trump are reportedly expressing dissent and concern about these actions.