Skip to main content

Judge Orders Release of Mr. Abrego from Unlawful Custody

MSW MediaDecember 11, 202529 min2,921 views
32 connections·40 entities in this video

Historic Ruling on Unlawful Detention

  • ⚖️ Judge Cenis has ordered the immediate release of Mr. Abrego from US custody, ruling his detention unlawful.
  • 📌 The core of the ruling states there was no existing removal order on the books since October 10th, 2019, rendering his incarceration unlawful.
  • 🏛️ This decision is seen as a significant embarrassment for figures like Christine Nome, Tom Homan, and Donald Trump, who asserted he would never walk free.

Legal Precedent and Government Misconduct

  • 📜 Judge Cenis's 31-page ruling, described as "blistering," cites Supreme Court precedent like Zenvidis but finds it insufficient as there was no removal order at all.
  • ⚠️ The ruling highlights that the government affirmatively misled the tribunal regarding Costa Rica's willingness to accept Mr. Abrego.
  • 📰 A Washington Post article is cited twice, confirming Costa Rica's position that they never closed the door, contradicting government filings made under seal.

Case History and Allegations

  • ✈️ The case traces back to the Trump administration, which allegedly sent Mr. Abrego to El Salvador without due process, despite a court order barring his removal.
  • ⛓️ He endured detention and alleged torture in El Salvador's Secot prison before being ordered released by multiple courts, including the Supreme Court.
  • ⚖️ Upon returning to the US, he faced prosecution on smuggling charges and was subsequently placed in immigration detention.

Government's Pursuit of Removal

  • 🌍 The government repeatedly attempted to deport Mr. Abrego to various countries, including Uganda, Ghana, Eswatini, and Liberia, facing rejections from the first three.
  • 🤝 Costa Rica was initially presented as an option, but the government's claims about its withdrawal were later exposed as misleading.
  • 📉 Mr. Abrego rejected a plea deal that would have sent him to Costa Rica, opting instead to fight the charges at trial.

Future Legal Steps and Independent Media

  • 🧐 Judge Cenis noted the government's defiance of court orders and will consider this conduct in pending motions, potentially leading to sanctions.
  • 📰 The importance of independent media like All Rise News and The Breakdown is emphasized for covering these cases and holding the government accountable.
  • 🎤 Whistleblower testimony from Aryeh Neier is expected in related contempt proceedings, potentially shedding further light on the government's actions.
Knowledge graph40 entities · 32 connections

How they connect

An interactive map of every person, idea, and reference from this conversation. Hover to trace connections, click to explore.

Hover · drag to explore
40 entities
Chapters11 moments

Key Moments

Transcript108 segments

Full Transcript

Topics15 themes

What’s Discussed

Unlawful DetentionRemoval OrderJudge CenisHabeas CorpusDue ProcessImmigration DetentionDeportationCosta RicaEl SalvadorSecot PrisonChristine NomeTrump AdministrationAll Rise NewsIndependent MediaSanctions
Smart Objects40 · 32 links
Companies· 6
People· 13
Locations· 7
Concepts· 11
Medias· 2
Event· 1