Brooklyn Principal Denies Holocaust Survivor Speaking Opportunity Over Israel-Palestine Views

Holocaust Survivor Excluded from School Speaking Engagement

• 85-year-old Holocaust survivor Sammy Styman reports being denied an invitation to speak at Brooklyn Middle School 447.
• The principal, Aaron Rush, cited concerns that Styman's messages on Israel and Palestine were not suitable for a public school setting, despite his 15 years of speaking to NYC students.

Survivor's Perspective and Concerns

• Styman, who experienced a labor camp and starvation as a child, emphasizes the importance of teaching students to "teach the heart" alongside the mind.
• He expressed confusion and a desire to understand the principal's reasoning, stating that being proud of his Jewish identity should not disqualify him as a speaker.

Zionism, Israel, and Censorship Allegations

• Styman's presentation materials included slides with Israeli flags and an explanation of Zionism.
• Mosha Spurn, president of United Jewish Teachers, views the decision as part of a trend to separate Jews from Israel and the Holocaust from Jewish identity and Israel.
• Spurn warns against censorship and the shutting out of Jewish viewpoints, especially from Holocaust survivors.

Official Responses and Mayor's Statement

• The Department of Education stated their belief in educating children about acceptance and the consequences of intolerance and hate.
• A representative mentioned the chancellor contacted Styman to discuss student engagement plans.
• The Mayor publicly supported Styman, calling him the "right person to speak with kids about the Holocaust."