Asus ROG Xbox Ally X Review: Powerful PC Handheld, But With Caveats

Introduction to the ROG Xbox Ally and Ally X

• 💡 The ROG Xbox Ally and Ally X are Windows-based gaming handhelds developed in partnership with Xbox, aiming to streamline the PC gaming experience.
• 🎯 They offer comfortable grips, access to multiple gaming storefronts, and offline access to Xbox Game Pass titles.

Xbox Game Library and Cloud Gaming

• 🎮 The Ally is best viewed as a handheld PC, meaning only Xbox games with Xbox Play Anywhere support or those on the PC marketplace are playable.
• ☁️ Unlike the Steam Deck, which relies on cloud gaming requiring a constant connection, the Ally can download Game Pass titles for offline play, a significant advantage for travelers.
• 💰 While Game Pass offers extensive library access, subscription costs can add up, though new Ally purchasers receive a complimentary 3-month premium tier.

Design, Ergonomics, and Specs

• 🕹️ The handhelds boast comfortable, Xbox controller-like grips and smooth analog sticks, with a design reminiscent of the PlayStation Portal.
• ⚙️ Key features include a Command Center button for performance tweaks and a Library button for accessing games.
• ⚠️ The placement of the start menu button and the design of the programmable M1/M2 back buttons are noted as ergonomic drawbacks.
• 🚀 The Ally X represents a significant upgrade with a more powerful processor, increased memory and storage, and a larger battery compared to the standard Ally and Steam Deck OLED.

Windows vs. Linux and Game Performance

• 💻 The Windows operating system offers broader game support, especially for titles with anti-cheat software that are often incompatible with the Steam Deck's Linux OS.
• ⚡ In direct comparisons, the Ally X generally outperforms the Steam Deck OLED in both resolution and frame rates across various games, particularly demanding titles.
• ⚠️ While the Ally X excels with graphically intense games, the Steam Deck may suffice for less demanding titles, offering a cost-saving alternative.

Bugs, Quirks, and Value Proposition

• 🐞 The reviewer encountered numerous bugs and input issues with the Ally, including lost controller input, problems waking from sleep, and Windows OS conflicts, which detract from the user experience.
• 🧩 The Windows OS on the Ally often feels intrusive, unlike the Steam Deck's streamlined big picture mode, leading to a less cohesive gaming experience.
• 💸 Despite superior performance, the Ally's high price point ($600 for the standard, $1000 for the X) makes it a difficult recommendation compared to more affordable options like the Steam Deck or Switch 2, especially given the recurring bugs.
• 🎒 The lack of an included carrying case for the Ally is a notable omission, requiring an additional purchase.