Andrew Barth Feldman Takes Over ‘Maybe Happy Ending’ on Broadway | What to Expect

Andrew Barth Feldman Joins Broadway's 'Maybe Happy Ending'

• 💡 Andrew Barth Feldman is set to take over the lead role of Oliver in the Tony Award-winning musical "Maybe Happy Ending" on Broadway.
• 🎭 His engagement is a 9-week limited run, beginning September 2nd and concluding November 1st.
• 🔄 Feldman replaces Darren Criss, who recently won a Tony Award for originating the role of Oliver.

About the New Star & Production

• 🌟 Feldman is known for his previous Broadway role as the title character in "Dear Evan Hansen" and appearances in "No Hard Feelings" and "Little Shop of Horrors."
• ❤️ He will star opposite Helen J. Shen, who plays Claire and is also his real-life girlfriend, continuing the show's exploration of connection.
• 🏆 "Maybe Happy Ending" secured six Tony Awards in 2025, including Best Musical, Best Book for Aronson and Park, and Best Direction for Ardan.

The Story and Creative Vision

• 🤖 The musical tells the captivating story of Oliver and Claire, two abandoned helperbots who discover love and heartbreak as their manufacturer's warranty nears its end.
• 💖 The creative team, including writers Will Aronson and Hugh Park and director Michael Ardan, expressed their excitement for Feldman's "fresh and moving take" on the role.
• ✨ They emphasized the show's universal themes of longing for connection and the complexities of identity, welcoming diverse interpretations in casting.

Future Plans and Discussion Points

• 🚀 A national tour for "Maybe Happy Ending" is already slated to embark in Fall 2026.
• 💬 The quick recasting has sparked discussion about whether it keeps the production fresh or risks overshadowing Darren Criss's award-winning original performance.
• 🌍 The casting also marks the first time the role of Oliver will be played by a white actor, adding another dimension to the discussion.