Martin Amis and Ian Buruma on Monsters: A New Yorker Festival Discussion
The New YorkerJuly 22, 201447 min18,598 views
34 connectionsΒ·40 entities in this videoβThe Allure of Monstrosity for Writers
- π‘ Writers are often drawn to the subject of monsters, whether political, psychological, or simply ugly, as a compelling topic for exploration.
- π Russian fiction under repression is cited as an example where external monstrous forces shaped literary output, making it a response to political environments.
- π§ The appeal for writers isn't merely about sensationalism or "good copy," but about understanding the transformation of individuals and the nature of evil.
Understanding the Nature of Monsters
- π Ian Buruma investigated how an ordinary person, like the killer of Theo van Gogh, could become a brutal murderer, exploring the circumstances that transform personality.
- π Martin Amis distinguishes between "big monsters" (e.g., Stalin, Hitler) who act on a grand stage, and "little monsters" who are created by the former's influence through "priority magic" and "moral nullity."
- π The "artist monkey" archetype, exemplified by figures like Hitler and Mao, describes individuals with destructive ingenuity who apply artistic nastiness to real life.
Case Studies: Historical and Modern Examples
- π Stalin is described as a more interesting fictional character than Hitler due to his devilish intelligence and sadism, while Hitler was a more boring fanatic.
- π Osama bin Laden is presented as a "self-creative monster" who radicalized himself and used terror as a PR move, embodying a "death cult" mentality.
- β οΈ Islamism is viewed as a death cult, similar to Nazism and Bolshevism, characterized by the drastic demotion of human life, the rejection of reason, and a childish pleasure in destruction.
Factors Contributing to Radicalization
- π± Religious cults and extreme political movements find fertile ground on university campuses, attracting vulnerable young people seeking meaning and susceptible to plausible narratives.
- π¬ Humiliation and grievance are key triggers for radicalization, particularly among second-generation immigrants who feel disconnected and easily bruised.
- π« Misogyny and the hatred of women are highlighted as central to certain extremist ideologies, such as the Taliban, who enforce extreme Puritanism and control over women's lives.
The Universal Potential for Violence
- β‘ The appeal of "righteous violence" is seen as limitless, allowing individuals to behave barbarically while believing they are justified.
- π¨ The doctrine of "takfeer" in Islamism grants individuals the power to judge and eliminate those deemed infidels or apostates, leading to extreme atrocities.
- π§ The potential for abuse exists in all human beings; when one person is given total power over another, it almost invariably leads to some form of abuse, if not torture and murder.
- π¨βπ§βπ¦ Martin Amis's personal shift to writing about geopolitics and masculinity was influenced by becoming a father and the events of 9/11, prompting him to explore the "weird outfit" of the Islamist suicide bomber.
Knowledge graph40 entities Β· 34 connections
How they connect
An interactive map of every person, idea, and reference from this conversation. Hover to trace connections, click to explore.
Hover Β· drag to explore
40 entities
Chapters16 moments
Key Moments
Transcript169 segments
Full Transcript
Topics15 themes
Whatβs Discussed
Monsters in writingPolitical monstersPsychological monstersStalinHitlerOsama bin LadenIslamismDeath cultsRejection of reasonRadicalizationHumiliationMisogynyViolenceHuman behaviorGeopolitics
Smart Objects40 Β· 34 links
PeopleΒ· 18
CompanyΒ· 1
ConceptsΒ· 13
MediasΒ· 4
EventsΒ· 2
LocationsΒ· 2