Skip to main content

7 Terrifying Urban Legends Based on True Stories

Lets Read!June 4, 202158 min333,956 views
22 connections·40 entities in this video→

The Leaping Lawyer: Gary Hoy

  • βš–οΈ The urban legend of a lawyer who died showing off an office window's strength is based on the true story of Gary Hoy in Toronto.
  • 🏒 Hoy, an engineer and lawyer, died in 1993 when he ran into a window on the 24th floor of the Toronto Dominion Centre.
  • πŸ’₯ Contrary to the legend, the glass didn't break; rusty screws failed, causing the pane to slip out of its frame.
  • πŸ“‰ Hoy's death contributed to the eventual closure of his law firm, Holden Day Wilson, one of the largest in Canadian history at the time.

The Candyman's Real-Life Inspiration: Ruthie Mae McCoy

  • πŸ“ž The legend of Bloody Mary and the Candyman, who appear when summoned in mirrors, is linked to the tragic case of Ruthie Mae McCoy.
  • πŸšͺ In 1987, McCoy called 911 reporting intruders trying to enter her 11th-floor Chicago apartment through her bathroom cabinet.
  • πŸ•΅οΈ Police discovered McCoy had been shot multiple times and that her killers had entered and exited through a secret passage behind her bathroom cabinet, connecting to an adjacent apartment.
  • 🏘️ This architectural flaw in the Ablah Projects allowed for easy access for burglars and criminals, a problem residents had complained about.

The Dead Body Under the Bed: Sonny Millbrook

  • πŸ›Œ The urban legend of a couple finding a decomposing body under their motel bed is a true story involving Sonny Millbrook.
  • 🏨 In 2010, James and Rhonda Sargent complained of a foul odor in room 222 of the Budget Lodge Inn in Memphis, Tennessee, where they had slept on the bed.
  • πŸ’€ Detectives later found the body of Sonny Millbrook, who had been murdered by her boyfriend, Lakeith Moody, and concealed under the bed.
  • ⚠️ The motel staff had cleaned the room and rented it out multiple times after Millbrook's disappearance before her body was discovered.

Rats in the Toilet: Seattle Sewer Rats

  • 🚽 The unsettling urban legend of creatures swimming up sewage pipes into toilets is a reality, particularly with sewer rats.
  • πŸ€ In King County, Seattle, rodent control specialist Don Pace reports 50-80 toilet rat incidents annually, with over 400 reported in the last decade.
  • ⚠️ These rats, often Norway rats, can enter homes through sewage systems, especially in older plumbing, and are known for spreading disease.
  • πŸ’§ Simple measures like closing the toilet lid and using dish soap to break surface tension can help deter them.

Alligators in the Sewers: New York City

  • 🐊 While often dismissed as myth, there's evidence of alligators in American sewer systems, though their survival is limited.
  • πŸ“° Reports of alligators in New York City's sewers date back decades, with some accounts from former sewer officials.
  • 🐊 In 2010, a two-foot alligator was found in Queens, New York, confirming sightings are not entirely fabricated, though they likely don't survive long-term due to cold weather.
  • 🐊 Florida alligators have been cited in sewers, especially during storm surges, supplementing their diet with rats.

Cropsey: Andre Rand

  • πŸ”ͺ The Staten Island urban legend of Cropsey, a boogeyman with a hook for a hand who abducted children, is based on the real criminal Andre Rand.
  • 🏫 Rand worked as a custodian at the Willowbrook State School, a facility for children with disabilities that was later closed due to poor conditions.
  • πŸ‘§ Rand was convicted of kidnapping Hollyanne Hughes and Jennifer Swagger, and suspected in the disappearances of other children.
  • πŸ’” His crimes instilled terror in the Staten Island community, leaving a lasting psychological trauma.

Charlie No-Face: Ray Robinson

  • ⚑ The legend of Charlie No-Face, also known as the Green Man, is based on the tragic life of Ray Robinson.
  • πŸ€• In 1919, an eight-year-old Robinson survived a severe electrical accident that disfigured his face, burning away his eyes, nose, and ears, and causing him to lose a hand.
  • πŸšΆβ€β™‚οΈ Kept isolated by his family, Robinson eventually began nightly walks, becoming a local legend known for his unusual appearance and gentle nature.
  • ❀️ Despite his disfigurement, many locals showed him compassion, offering him cigarettes and beer, and some credit him with helping them through difficult times.
Knowledge graph40 entities Β· 22 connections

How they connect

An interactive map of every person, idea, and reference from this conversation. Hover to trace connections, click to explore.

Hover Β· drag to explore
40 entities
Chapters20 moments

Key Moments

Transcript213 segments

Full Transcript

Topics14 themes

What’s Discussed

Urban LegendsTrue CrimeGary HoyCandymanRuthie Mae McCoySonny MillbrookSewer RatsAlligators in SewersAndre RandCropseyRay RobinsonCharlie No-FaceFolkloreScary Stories
Smart Objects40 Β· 22 links
PeopleΒ· 14
LocationsΒ· 9
CompaniesΒ· 3
EventsΒ· 3
MediasΒ· 4
ProductΒ· 1
ConceptsΒ· 6